Does your library need to delete old events from your Facebook account? It’s a great question that came in from a viewer. I’ve got three questions to ask yourself before you hit the “delete” button in this episode.
Plus we’ll give kudos to a library with a fantastic YouTube short that puts a library spin on an iconic sporting event.
Do you have a suggestion for a topic for a future episode? Want to nominate someone for kudos? Let me know here. And thanks for watching!โ
Subscribe to this blog and youโll receive an email whenever I post. To do that, enter your email address. Then click on the โFollowโ button in the lower left-hand corner of the page. You can also follow me on the following social media platforms:
A librarian from Sweden is celebrating a victory after her library’s Facebook page was disabled, without warning, by Meta. Isabelle, a communications librarian, fought for months to get her library’s Facebook page back online after it was taken down by the platform.
Isabelle began working as a librarian in 2006 and took on a communications role in August of 2021. The lengths her library had to go through in order to get their page back are pretty mind-boggling.
Isabelle was kind enough to share the saga, in hopes that she might help other libraries.
How was your library was using Facebook for promotion before your account was disabled?
We mostly used it as a platform for promoting events, exhibitions, storytime sessions, and reading recommendations. It was also used for crucial information that had to be communicated to the public, like if our system was down and how it would impact the service we could provide to them. In short: it was used for both important and entertaining content. It was also a bit of measurement for what our patrons were satisfied with.
When was the account disabled and how did you first realize what had happened?
The first page got disabled before my time, on inexplicable grounds. It had been so for almost six months. I launched a brand-new page that also got disabled after two weeks in October 2021. I got notified by email from the “Facebook team” in a no-reply email. The email also contained the message “If you think your page was wrongly disabled, click here”, providing a broken link.
Tell me about the process of trying to get your account re-enabled.
At first, I tried to get in touch with the Swedish branch of Meta by writing an explanatory public post on LinkedIn. I tagged the Swedish country director Sam Rihani and the corporate communications manager, Lukasz Lindell. None of them replied although people of course reacted to my post. Our library wasnโt the only one whose Facebook page had been disabled by Meta.
After many fruitless attempts to get in touch with Facebook and some of its employees, I turned to the communications team at the council house in my municipality. It was obvious that we needed to take this case to another level.
Two communication specialists were consulted and one of them had a Facebook Business account. It was the only way to get in touch with some kind of non-automated customer support (i.e., an actual human being.) I made one communication specialist an admin of the disabled Facebook page, and a couple of months later, our Facebook page was finally re-enabled.
During the process, Meta wanted us to give them specific information about why the previous Facebook page was shut down. This was information that I didn’t have because nobody knew the circumstances even when it happened, and I wasn’t employed by the library at the time. If pages and accounts get disabled with no more specific information than “violation of community standardsโ, thatโs all the information we can give.
How did being disabled from Facebook impact your library’s ability to reach your community?
It was a bit of a blow, considering that we had invested so much time in promoting the page to our patrons. Some of them wondered where we had gone when the page was disabled.
On top of that, it happened the day before we were to release the much-awaited news about our printer/copy machine being re-installed. People who needed help applying for jobs, residential permits, and other urgent matters had been asking us for months. I had promised them that I would break the news on our Facebook page as soon as it was possible to print again.
But we still had Instagram and our website. I thought that if Meta didnโt want us on Facebook, I would downgrade its importance to being an optional channel more than something essential. I invested a lot of work in upgrading our library website so that all the information that the public needed was to be found there.
Even though not all our patrons have access to the internet, it was still a bit reassuring for them to know that all the information they needed about the library, events, and more could be found in that one place. Thatโs where we channeled everything that also should have been posted on our Facebook page. No information was lost, but it was a bit scattered instead of concentrated on the Facebook page.
I also make posters and flyers that are popular amongst people with limited access to the internet. When Facebook re-enabled our Facebook page, I was like: โOh? OK. Let me just get this thing out on the library website first.โ
What lessons or advice do you have for other libraries, having been through this tumultuous process?
Donโt put all your eggs in one basket, especially not when it comes to social media. Your content never really exclusively belongs to you and can be taken down by external agents who have no clue about your job.
I would advise librarians to invest time, money, and energy into building up their own websites where they can control and own their content. Direct patrons to that one website primarily for important news.
Also, donโt underestimate the usefulness of analog information like posters and flyers. They are essential for many patrons who lack the ability to search the web. Itโs way too easy to believe that โeveryoneโs on the internetโ or โeveryoneโs on Facebookโ but that isnโt true.
Use social media for lighter content: info bites, book recommendations, humorous posts, and the like. I think thatโs what people expect to find on Facebook anyway.
Libraries are the epitome of quality content and should not bow to corporations that choose to disable them.
Subscribe to this blog and youโll receive an email every time I post. To do that, enter your email address and click on the โFollowโ button in the lower left-hand corner of the page.
Angela answers a viewer question from a librarian at Pearsall Public Library. This librarian feels like she’s “drowning” on Facebook. She wanted to know if there were any libraries doing a great job on Facebook right now. The answer is…yes! Watch for my picks and add your own library Facebook page to the comments.
Also Kudos to everyone doing curbside service videos.
Don’t forget to subscribe to this series to get a new video tip for libraries each week! Thanks for watching.
This blog consists of my own personal opinions and may not represent those of my employer. Subscribe to this blog and youโll receive an email every time I post. To do that, click on โFollowโ button in the bottom left-hand corner of the page. Connect with me on Twitter,Instagram, and LinkedIn.
This week, Facebook announced it is making another change in the way the social media platform chooses to show content to its users. The big shift, as you likely know by now, is that Facebook will prioritize posts from friends and family in its news feed over public content from pages, like that of your library. In particular, the Facebook team will give top priority to posts that drive conversation between friends and family.
The announcement is causing consternation for many libraries, which relyย heavily on organic, unpaid traffic for their promotional efforts. I honestly don’t know what the end effect will be. I have the same worries as most of my library colleagues. We’ve adjusted well since the last major algorithm change in 2015. So will we have to start over? In the wake of this announcement, I’ve wondered if the chicken comes before the egg. In other words, do our well-performing posts get more interaction because, prior to this week, Facebook has shown them to people in anticipation of interaction… or do they perform well because people are interacting with them? (Deep thoughts!!)
In the Facebook group, Libraries and Social Media, I asked social media marketers at libraries to comment on the change. Caleb Sheaffer of Shreve Memorial Library in Shreveport, LA said, “I never know what to expect until it actually happens. Right now, all the posts that perform well for our library are ones that have the most interaction anyway.”
Jennifer Redford from Boise, Idaho added, “I think that weโll just need to focus more on writing and sharing great content. Weโve also started using events more and I wonder how that will be affected by the change.”
Finally, Molly Wetta, manager of the Santa Barbara Public Library, told me, “These announcements are pushing me to move forward more quickly with an idea I’ve had for a while. We’re experimenting with linked groups – I started one for youth services specific content, and we may also try one for smaller communities and branches within our system if this one is successful. The goals are to work more to create community connections in addition to marketing our events/services. I do love the events feature, and the notifications will hopefully be helpful but not intrusive. We’ll be sharing book recommendations and answering book-related questions, sharing early literacy tips and activities, and hopefully answering questions.”
The bottom line is that your library’s page may see your overall statistics drop. Your reachย and referral traffic, your shares, and your comments may drop. MAY is the key word there. My overall impression of this change is that it will force library marketers to work smarter when using Facebook. All of the pointers in this recent article on Facebook still apply.
And now, more than ever, you must make sure your posts are really good. Share content from other sources related to books and literature–don’t just promote your own stuff, particularly on posts. Use events to promote your events. Ask questions. Create polls. And most importantly, shoot video. As we know, Facebook users respond in a big way to video. Facebook says live videos often lead to discussion among viewers and live videos get six times as many interactions as regular videos. So video marketing must be part of your plan.
You can also explain to your followers what is happening and ask them to choose to see your posts. People who want to see more posts from your library page can selectย See First in News Feed Preferences.ย You can also do what Molly’s library is doing and experiment with groups. One of my favorite Facebook pages did that this weekend and they put a little money behind it to make sure all their followers know about the move.
Finally, don’t bait people to interact with your posts. In this week’s announcement, Facebook made it very clear that they will penalize pages which use engagement bait, like. Use real questions and conversation starters. Read this article to see how to avoid engagement bait.
Hereโs the thing to remember: posting content on Facebook is like building your house on rented land. It doesnโt belong to you and as much as it pains your library system when changes are made, there is little we can do about it. The big lesson is that we need to start relying on our own platforms and websites for promoting our programs and services. That means we should be building our own audience with blogs, podcasts, and other content delivery systems. We should be developing email subscriber lists so we can target and market to our specific library cardholders and give them the content they really want.
Facebook is great, but they’re not the only way to reach customers. Let’s make a concerted effort to start moving to other content delivery platforms where we have more control. Our fans are loyal and they’ll respond when we deliver content specifically targeted to them.
Subscribe to this blog and youโllย receiveย an emailย every time I post. To do that, click on โFollowโ button on the bottom left-hand corner of the page. Connect with me on Twitter and Snapchatโitโs where I talk about library marketing! Iโmย @Webmastergirl.ย Iโm also onย LinkedIn,ย Instagramย andย Pinterest.ย Views in this post are my own and do not represent those of my employer.